BeNewz
Related Articles
Aftab Maken
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan must collect Rs322 billion from court rulings before IMF board review, as authorities scramble to offset a major tax shortfall and unlock $1.2 billion in fresh financing.
Pakistan’s International Monetary Fund has imposed a key prior action requiring the Federal Board of Revenue to recover Rs322 billion from court-adjudicated tax disputes before its executive board considers the next loan tranche, officials said.
The condition was agreed during recent negotiations that led to a staff-level agreement under the Extended Fund Facility, as the IMF expressed concern over weak revenue performance and governance gaps within the tax machinery. Authorities said the recovery would largely come from super tax cases where courts have already issued rulings by end-February.
Officials confirmed that the FBR is pursuing both principal tax amounts and late payment surcharges of up to 25%, significantly boosting the expected inflows. The government has already collected a substantial portion of the disputed sums and expects to meet the full target before Pakistan’s case is circulated to the IMF board, likely in early May.
Upon approval, Pakistan is set to receive about $1 billion under the EFF and an additional $210 million through the Resilience and Sustainability Facility, taking total disbursements under the programmes to roughly $4.5 billion. The inflows are critical for stabilising foreign exchange reserves and meeting external financing needs amid continued macroeconomic pressure.
The IMF’s insistence on the prior action follows a widening gap in tax collection. The FBR has missed its original target for the first eight months of the current fiscal year by Rs640 billion, reflecting weak performance in key sectors such as power, oil, and gas. These sectors historically contribute a large share of indirect taxes, making their slowdown particularly damaging for revenue mobilisation.
Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio remains among the lowest in the region, hovering near 9–10% in recent years, according to State Bank of Pakistan data. Economists say this structural weakness has long constrained fiscal space, forcing repeated reliance on external borrowing and IMF programmes. The current $7 billion EFF, approved in 2024, is Pakistan’s 24th IMF programme, underscoring persistent fiscal vulnerabilities.
FBR officials told the IMF that part of the revenue shortfall was offset during the first half of the fiscal year through higher petroleum levy collections and provincial cash surpluses. Additional fiscal relief came from lower-than-expected flood-related expenditures and repayments from state-owned enterprises linked to circular debt settlement in the power sector.
Pakistan’s petroleum levy has emerged as a key non-tax revenue source, contributing over Rs700 billion annually in recent years, according to finance ministry data. However, analysts caution that reliance on such levies is volatile and tied to global oil price movements, limiting its sustainability as a fiscal anchor.
Amid rising tax disputes and administrative challenges, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has constituted a high-level task force to overhaul the FBR’s legal and litigation framework. The move signals growing urgency within the government to address systemic inefficiencies that delay tax recovery and weaken enforcement.
The task force will review operations across all adjudication levels, including tax departments, appellate tribunals, High Courts, and the Supreme Court. It aims to identify structural bottlenecks, resource gaps, and procedural inefficiencies that contribute to prolonged litigation and delayed revenue realisation.
Chaired by Shad Mohammad and including senior constitutional lawyer Hafiz Ahsaan Ahmad Khokhar, the body will propose reforms to build a more data-driven and coordinated litigation strategy. Officials said improving legal capacity is essential, as billions of rupees remain locked in disputes for years, undermining fiscal planning.
According to FBR estimates, tax litigation cases exceeding Rs 2 trillion are pending across various judicial forums, highlighting the scale of the problem. Experts note that slow dispute resolution not only delays revenue collection but also discourages compliance and investment.
The IMF has also raised concerns about internal governance within the FBR, indicating that previous reform efforts have yet to yield fully effective results. Strengthening institutional capacity, improving audit systems, and reducing discretionary powers remain central to the Fund’s reform agenda.
Pakistan’s broader fiscal outlook remains tied to its ability to implement these reforms. The government has committed to maintaining primary surpluses and controlling expenditures under IMF conditions, while also expanding the tax base through enforcement and digitalisation measures.
The success of the Rs 322 billion recovery drive will be a key test of these commitments. Meeting the prior action could unlock critical financing and reinforce investor confidence, while failure may delay programme approvals and strain external accounts. With negotiations entering a decisive phase, the IMF’s focus on enforcement and governance signals a shift toward deeper structural reforms. The outcome will shape Pakistan’s fiscal trajectory and determine the pace of future disbursements under the IMF programme.
