BeNewz
Related Articles
Aftab Maken
ISLAMABAD: PTCL Group has reported a notable turnaround in its latest financial results, posting a net profit of Rs. 3.07 billion. While this marks a significant recovery from previous losses, a closer examination of the financials reveals several underlying weaknesses that could challenge the sustainability of this performance.
One of the most prominent concerns is the sharp rise in operating expenses. Administrative and general expenses surged by 48% to Rs. 12.38 billion, while selling and marketing expenses jumped 60% to Rs. 6.32 billion. This steep increase reflects higher overheads, largely attributed to integration and promotional costs following the consolidation of Telenor Pakistan. While such expenditures may be necessary in the short term to support expansion and integration, they are likely to exert pressure on margins if not controlled effectively.
Another area of concern is the decline in other income, which dropped by 29% to Rs. 3.95 billion. This category has historically provided a cushion to the company’s earnings, and its contraction reduces a key source of non-operating support. As a result, the group’s reliance on core operational efficiency becomes even more critical going forward.
Finance costs also moved upward, increasing by 10% to Rs. 14.87 billion. This rise highlights the ongoing burden of debt servicing, exacerbated by elevated interest rates. PTCL’s leverage position remains a structural issue, with accumulated losses exceeding Rs. 50 billion as of FY25. The persistence of high finance costs continues to weigh heavily on profitability and limits financial flexibility.
Taxation further impacted the bottom line. The group recorded a tax charge of Rs. 2.12 billion, compared to a tax credit of Rs. 1.58 billion in the same period last year. This shift significantly reduced the net benefit from pre-tax earnings and underscores the variability of tax-related impacts on overall profitability.
Despite returning to profit, the company did not announce any shareholder payouts. The board declared no cash dividend, bonus shares, or other entitlements. While this is common for companies in a turnaround phase seeking to retain earnings for stability and growth, it may disappoint income-focused investors.
A critical aspect of the reported profit is its reliance on non-recurring and one-off factors. The bottom line was supported by a reversal in expected credit losses amounting to Rs. 52.7 million, compared to a substantial provision of Rs. 5.22 billion in the same period last year. Such reversals are not sustainable sources of income and may not be repeated in future periods.
Moreover, a significant portion of the group’s impressive growth figures—58% increase in revenue and a 564% surge in operating profit—was driven by the inclusion of Telenor Pakistan’s results from January 1, 2026. Organic growth, particularly in the standalone wireline segment, remained modest at around 6.5%, indicating that the core business is still facing challenges.
Looking at the broader picture, the ongoing integration of Telenor Pakistan with Ufone presents execution risks, potential regulatory hurdles, and the likelihood of additional costs. Historical issues such as high debt levels, pension liabilities, and provisioning requirements for UBank continue to cast a shadow over the company’s financial outlook.
Notably, standalone PTCL (wireline) reported a relatively modest net profit of approximately Rs. 0.9 billion. This suggests that the group’s turnaround is being driven more by its mobile and banking segments rather than its traditional core operations.
In summary, while PTCL Group’s return to profitability is a positive development, the results remain fragile. Rising costs, heavy debt, and reliance on one-off gains highlight the need for sustained operational improvements to ensure long-term financial stability.
